KM Steele (2023) After Universal Design Book Chapter – “Shaping Inclusive and Equitable Makerspaces”

Book Chapter in After Universal Design: The Disability Design Revolution, Edited by Elizabeth Guffey

Makerspaces are often used to help build new assistive technology and increase accessibility; however, many of these spaces and tools remain inaccessible. We need to make sure disabled people can access these spaces and create the products and designs that they actually want.
– DO-IT Scholar

Dr. Steele was asked to contribute a case study focused on her work with AccessEngineering into Shaping Inclusive and Equitable Makerspaces.

Description: How might we develop products made with and by disabled users rather than for them? Could we change living and working spaces to make them accessible rather than designing products that “fix” disabilities? How can we grow our capabilities to make designs more “bespoke” to each individual? After Universal Design brings together scholars, practitioners, and disabled users and makers to consider these questions and to argue for the necessity of a new user-centered design.

As many YouTube videos demonstrate, disabled designers are not only fulfilling the grand promises of DIY design but are also questioning what constitutes meaningful design itself. By forcing a rethink of the top-down professionalized practice of Universal Design, which has dominated thinking and practice around design for disability for decades, this book models what inclusive design and social justice can look like as activism, academic research, and everyday life practices today.

With chapters, case studies, and interviews exploring questions of design and personal agency, hardware and spaces, the experiences of prosthetics’ users, conventional hearing aid devices designed to suit personal style, and ways of facilitating pain self-reporting, these essays expand our understanding of what counts as design by offering alternative narratives about creativity and making. Using critical perspectives on disability, race, and gender, this book allow us to understand how design often works in the real world and challenges us to rethink ideas of “inclusion” in design.

Spasticity Research Award Nominations

Nicole Zaino (wearing glasses) poses on campus

Walking takes energy – but for kids with cerebral palsy, walking can be exhausting. The average child with cerebral palsy consumes two times the amount of energy during walking compared to typically-developing peers – that is the equivalent of jogging or climbing stairs!

The reasons for why walking takes so much energy for children with cerebral palsy remains largely unknown. The extra muscle activity caused by spasticity has often been theorized as a large contributing factor. If this was true, we would expect that treatments that reduce spasticity, like selective dorsal rhizotomy, could dramatically reduce energy during walking.

Led by Nicole Zaino, a new PhD student in the lab, and our collaborator Mike Schwartz at Gillette Children’s Specialty we have been investigating this question. By analyzing energy consumption for children with cerebral palsy who underwent rhizotomy and matched peers with cerebral palsy, we were determined that reducing spasticity does not lead to dramatic decreases in energy consumption.

This research has been nominated as a finalist for two awards at the International Society of Biomechanics Conference. This work was selected as one of 5 finalist for the Clinical Biomechanics Award. Nicole will also present as one of the finalists for the David Winter Young Investigator Award. The final awards will be announced at the conference in Calgary the first week of August. Good luck Nicole!

You can learn more about the study and read the preprint on BioRxiv:

Spasticity reduction in children with cerebral palsy is not associated with reduced energy consumption during walking

Choi, H. Evaluation of Gait and Muscle Function with Ankle Foot Orthoses. PhD Dissertation.

 

A dissertation submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, University of Washington, 2016. To download and read in full, CLICK HERE. to access through the University of Washington’s ResearchWorks Archive.

A methods figure is shown depicting an Ultrasound Coordinate System. The figure depicts how the Achilles tendon length is quantified by using an ultrasound, participant, and modeling system with motion capture markers. [In photo text: Global Coordinate System; Ultrasound Coordinate System; Figure 19 Quantification of Achilles tendon length. On left, AFO, ultrasound, and position of experimental markers. On right, scaled musculoskeletal model and schematic of coordinate systems for ultrasound to define AT length.Background: Many individuals with cerebral palsy (CP) and stroke are prescribed ankle foot orthoses
(AFOs) for use during daily life. AFOs have been shown to improve pathologic gait and walking
speed in CP and stroke by providing support and alignment. There are many different types of
AFOs available such as posterior leaf spring AFOs, rigid AFOs, and articulated AFOs. Further,
there are many parameters that can be customized or tuned for each type of AFO, such as
stiffness, heel height, shank to vertical angle, and foot plate length. However, how different types
of AFOs and the customization of specific parameters impact muscle function remains unclear.

Purpose: The goals of this dissertation were to evaluate how different types of AFOs and different
tuning parameters impact gait kinematics and muscle function. Of particular interest is the
gastrocnemius, a key muscle that crosses the knee and ankle joints and is commonly tight among
individuals with CP or stroke. Gastrocnemius operating length, defined as the total muscle and
tendon length during a functional activity, influences ankle and knee kinematics during gait.

Results/Discussion: This dissertation provides important evidence for how humans adapt to various AFO
properties and suggests important implications for the design and prescription of AFOs. This
work provides a quantitative evaluation of how AFOs impact musculotendon dynamics among
individuals with stroke (Aim 1) and cerebral palsy (Aim 2). The fabrication methods in Aim 3
creates a powerful and flexible research platform for evaluating AFO design, which may be
extended to fabrication of AFOs for daily use with further improvements in additive
manufacturing materials and methods. The final study (Aim 4), provides the first experimental
evidence combining ultrasound and musculoskeletal modeling to understand how muscle and
tendon length are impacted by AFO design. These evaluations provide guidance for future AFO
design and prescription that can not only augment human mobility for unimpaired individuals,
but also provide improve metrics for improving function and guiding rehabilitation for
individuals with neurologic impairments.

Capacity Building Institute

CBI participants.The proceedings from AccessEngineering’s first Capacity Building Institute have been published on-line.

This institute focused on bringing together faculty, staff, and students from engineering departments around the country to discuss how to support individuals with disabilities in pursuing careers in engineering.

There were many wonderful presentations and discussions. In particular check out:

These discussions helped to inform several new resources from AccessEngineering including:

The Capacity Building Institute was hosted at the University of Washington-Seattle April 7-9, 2015. Please let us know if you are interested in participating next year!