MH Schwartz, KM Steele, AJ Ries, AG Georgiadis, BA MacWilliams (2022) “A model for understanding the causes and consequences of walking impairments”

Journal Article in PLOS ONE:

Causal inference is inherently ambiguous since we cannot observe multiple realizations of the same person with different characteristics. Causal models must be evaluated through indirect means and reasoning.

Aim: The main objectives in conducting this study were to (1) propose a comprehensive model for quantifying the causes and consequences of walking impairments and (2) demonstrate the potential utility of the model for supporting clinical care and addressing basic scientific questions related to walking.

Method: This paper introduced a model consisting of 10 nodes and 23 primary causal paths and demonstrated the model’s utility using a large sample of gait data.

Results: The model was plausible, captured some well-known cause-effect relationships, provided new insights into others, and generated novel hypotheses requiring further testing through simulation or experiment.

Interpretation: This model is a proposal that is meant to be critically evaluated, validated or refuted, altered, and improved over time. Such improvements might include the introduction of new nodes, variables, and paths.

BC Conner, AM Spomer, SSPA Bishe, KM Steele, ZF Lerner (2022) “Soleus H-reflex modulation in cerebral palsy and its relationship with neural control complexity: a pilot study”

Journal Article in Experimental Brain Research

Individuals with cerebral palsy (CP) display motor control patterns that suggest decreased supraspinal input, but it remains unknown if they are able to modulate lower-limb reflexes in response to more complex tasks, or whether global motor control patterns relate to reflex modulation capacity in this population.

Figure 1) Study design. (A) Task complexity protocol, where soleus H-reflexes were elicited with stimulation of the posterior tibial nerve under two conditions: a baseline, bilateral standing condition and a complex, unilateral standing condition (B) Walking ankle resistance protocol, where soleus H-reflexes were elicited during mid-stance under a baseline walking and when walking with an ankle exoskeleton device delivering resistance to plantar flexion proportional to a user’s real-time estimated ankle moment.Aim:  To further elucidate the multifaceted effects of CP on inhibitory and faciliatory supraspinal pathways and global measures of motor control, providing novel information for improving targeted neuromuscular interventions in this patient population.

Methods: Eight ambulatory individuals with CP (12–18 years old) were recruited to complete a task complexity protocol, where soleus H-reflex excitability was compared between bilateral (baseline) and unilateral (complex) standing. We also investigated the relationship between each participant’s ability to modulate soleus H-reflex excitability and the complexity of their walking neural control pattern determined from muscle synergy analysis. Finally, six of the eight participants completed an exoskeleton walking protocol, where soleus H-reflexes were collected during the stance phase of walking with and without stance-phase plantar flexor resistance.

Results: Participants displayed a significant reduction in soleus H-reflex excitability (− 26 ± 25%, p = 0.04) with unilateral standing, and a strong positive relationship was observed between more refined neural control during walking and an increased ability to modulate reflex excitability (R = 0.79, p = 0.04). There was no difference in neuromuscular outcome measures with and without the ankle exoskeleton (p values all > 0.05), with variable reflex responses to walking with ankle exoskeleton resistance.

Interpretation: These findings provide evidence that ambulatory individuals with CP retain some capacity to modulate lower-limb reflexes in response to increased task complexity, and that less refined neural control during walking appears to be related to deficits in reflex modulation.